Rule Breakers tells the success story of Afghan businesswoman Roya Mahboob. A story about an Afghan woman who broke free of religious and social pressures and gained enough fame to make her name known worldwide certainly sounds inspiring, especially when you consider that the situation in Afghanistan today is even worse than it was back then.
But let’s be honest. On the surface, the film carries nice messages telling women they can do anything they want. What I see underneath is a success narrative that whitewashes capitalism. While Afghan women live under the Taliban’s most severe human rights violations, the film essentially suggests that the path to women’s freedom runs through founding companies and entrepreneurship.
Admittedly, the film does show the real obstacles girls face: threats, pressure from family and society, and so on. But all of these obstacles lead to the same destination: individual success. Roya Mahboob, who is both one of the film’s producers and its lead, is elevated into a savior figure. At this point, I can’t help feeling that the film serves less as inspiration than as a showcase introducing Roya Mahboob to the world. Haven’t plenty of powerful people throughout history tried to polish their own image in just this way?
Imagine watching this film as a woman living in Afghanistan in 2025. There are so many stories waiting to be told, so many problems that need to come to light, and yet this is what gets presented to the world as an “inspiring feminist film.”
What’s more, the fact that the Taliban has banned girls from education beyond the sixth grade is dispatched in a single sentence at the very end, as the screen fades to black. That is all the space a two-hour film gives to present-day Afghanistan. In one scene, the women ask each other about their dreams. One says she wants to become a software engineer and start a company; another says a red convertible Mustang. I wonder: what are the dreams of Afghan women living under Taliban rule?
The film reminded me of a familiar Western narrative: the West brings its technology and its culture, its “civilization,” to a “backward” East. This narrative isn’t new. In the past, this kind of propaganda was made with more craft, so much so that it was hard even to notice. Today, even that craft is missing. They try to persuade the audience with a weak script, unconvincing dialogue, and visuals that resemble a commercial.
Perhaps the greatest “freedom” capitalism can offer women is encouraging them to found start-ups: an illusion of freedom within its own limits. Rule Breakers does exactly this by borrowing the language of feminism. It is so raw and unconvincing, both visually and narratively, that even Microsoft’s and Google’s International Women’s Day ads seem sincere by comparison.










