Seidel’s limited and talky tale of three landmen with opposing values is visually striking but overly stagey.
A story of twisting loyalties, identities and morality in one of the world’s most corrupt industries is the texture for writer-director Adam Seidel’s small scale drama Williston. Adapting his own play, his second narrative feature seeks to tell a tale that looms larger than its confined locations. With an admirably sharp eye and beautiful cinematography the film is lifted just above but can’t hold the entire weight of its theatrical ideas and predictable revelations.
Focusing on a triage of opposing forces we open on Barb (Geneva Carr) driving to Williston, North Dakota. She’s a seasoned “landman” on her way to try and tie up a tricky deal involving land rich for drilling owned by the oil industry adverse “Indian Jim” (Mike Mushultubbe Simpson). Upon arriving she’s greeted by the meek and naive Tom (Jonathan Lipnicki), a numbers guy who’s pretty green to the company but has been inexplicably rushed onto the deal himself. This is to the very apparent dissatisfaction of Barb’s jaded, sweary business partner Larry (Matt Walsh), also staying with the pair. But his old-school, blunt manner clashes with Tom and threatens to spill over into business-adverse hatred. Between them they must trust and navigate the various tensions and pressures of creating a solution that satisfies every party.
There’s a respectable clarity to Williston’s intentions even if they aren’t the most ambitious. As a playwright it is understandable why Seidel decided to shoot the majority of the film in the tiny room holding the trio prisoner. There’s a claustrophobia and rising tension, especially when things go wrong but it also feels like a story for the stage. As a film that questions the environmental impact of the business and the opposing feeling of the landowner, there’s actually very little conflict outside the central three. This is a contained, psychological approach to an expansive idea which can only sustain intermittent interest. Seidal’s and cinematographer Andrew Applyard’s clear talent for framing and atmosphere elevate much of the punchy dialogue but the film is never as volatile as its bigger moments may suggest.
While the central three all give committed performances it is Libnicki who offers the most. Tom is initially the type of bright eyed, bushy tailed guy you’d expect but evolves into something much more interesting. Walsh certainly gets his role but goes a bit too hard and his conviction is not always convincing. Similar with Carr who struggles to feel authentic in her louder moments and the heft of their musings is often drowned out by curses and quips. At least each character gets a shared, consistent amount of screen time that does make them feel slightly more rounded as things wrap up and things start to escalate. But if only the conflict and implications of huge American conglomerates and generational wealth crashing in and taking native American land was more fleshed out there might have been a more balanced film here.
2.5 / 5
Williston does much more than expected with its scrappy resources but never drills deep enough in its search for an original outcome.










