By Gordon Foote.
Carrying on from Land of Hope, I have another Eastern film on the block this week. Moving from Japan to South Korea, we have Nugu-ui ttal-do anin Haewon, or Nobody’s Daughter Haewon for those, like myself, whose only prior exposure to the Korean vernacular came courtesy of Psy and his delightful wee tune…
Nobody’s Daughter Haewon tells the straightforward story of a drama student and her professor as they continue an on/off relationship and… yeah, that’s kind of it. No subplots, no interweaving story arcs, no surrealistic undertones to keep things just weird enough to be interesting…just a bare bones, not-really-love story…. Having never seen any of Sang-Soo Hong’s films before, it’s difficult to gauge whether the sparse narrative is usually there to make room for other underlying issues, but in this case it’s really not. It’s just a film about a girl who is going out with a guy, then isn’t, then is again, then might be.
Occasionally, as if noticing the tumbleweeds, other issues are raised briefly, foremost amongst these being Professor Seongjun’s wife and young child. However, Haewon never seems especially concerned about her role as home-wrecker and, as such, it’s hard to see it as a real issue in the story. The ever-present threat of their relationship going public with the student body, too, is dealt with fairly early on in a painfully awkward scene leaving Haewon isolated from her peers and Seongjun embarrassingly marginalised in the eyes of his students, in essence, removing it as a threat.
It could be argued that there is a little more going on, as Haewon’s dips into increasingly ridiculous dreams where she is the focal point of male attention, thus countering her new-found loneliness and there is the hint (however poorly presented) that her grasp on reality is not what it might be, but neither of these points come to anything and only serve to give the film a weaker ending than was necessary to redeem it.
Nobody’s Daughter Haewon comes off like a bad Haruki Murakami novel (not that there are any, obviously!). It maintains the grounded, everyday, central focus but fails to present anything interesting enough to warrant that focus. The characters are unlikeable, their actions mundane, self-destructive even, and the story telling doesn’t go far enough to develop them so that we might understand why they are as they are. Haewon buoys between irritatingly fragile and bewilderingly unperturbed, while Professor Seongjun is more of a talking plot device than an actual person; a cliché wrapped up in a trope, the ageing teacher caught between his family and the young, attractive other option where responsibility and the weight of life seem further away….think I’ve seen this one before.
Similar to the story, things are skeletal on the technical side too. It is not really a mystery to me that Hong is a lovie of the award circuit, where stripped down production values can be passed off as edgy or artistic. In actuality, I found much of the camera work rudimentary with poor transitions and some painful zoom work.
Nugu-ui ttal-do anin Haewon is an inoffensive film which sets out to tell a very basic story and does so. Everything about it feels no-frills, from the direction, camera work, and even story content; its small scale and, seemingly, not trying to be anything more…so…there’s that, I guess.
2/5
We hope you're enjoying BRWC. You should check us out on our social channels, subscribe to our newsletter, and tell your friends. BRWC is short for battleroyalewithcheese.
Trending on BRWC:
Civil War: The BRWC Review
Puddysticks: Review
NO COMMENTS