Five Nights At Freddy’s 2: The BRWC Review
Emma Tammi’s Five Nights at Freddy’s 2 continues Blumhouse’s adaptation of Scott Cawthon’s immensely popular game franchise with a sequel that embraces deeper lore, stylish visual craftsmanship, and an expanded cast. It’s a film that clearly knows its audience, rewarding those invested in the mythology of Freddy Fazbear’s Pizza while offering newcomers a more emotionally anchored story through the perspectives of Mike (Josh Hutcherson), Vanessa (Elizabeth Lail), and especially young Abby (Piper Rubio). While the sequel improves on several aspects of its predecessor, it also retains some familiar limitations—especially when it comes to scare factor and pacing. The result is an enjoyable, stylish, and sometimes surprisingly moving supernatural horror film that fans will appreciate, even if it doesn’t fully maximize its horror potential.
Set one year after the events of the first film, Five Nights at Freddy’s 2 pushes its characters into new emotional territory. Mike Schmidt continues to grapple with guilt, trauma, and responsibility, and Hutcherson’s performance brings a weary sincerity to the role. His arc is less about physical survival and more about protecting Abby, confronting the past, and untangling decades-old tragedy. This makes him an empathetic protagonist, even as the story widens far beyond his immediate family.
Vanessa, played once again by Elizabeth Lail, receives far more emotional depth this time around. Her connection to her father William Afton remains a psychological wound the film examines thoughtfully, and Lail portrays Vanessa with a haunted intensity that gives her scenes a powerful undercurrent. Piper Rubio’s Abby, meanwhile, becomes the emotional core of the film. Her curiosity, vulnerability, and lingering connection to the animatronics offer the story a different perspective—one that blends innocence with an unsettling sense of complicity. Rubio’s growth as a performer is evident, and her scenes frequently carry the film.
New cast members—such as Mckenna Grace in a memorable supporting role—strengthen the ensemble. The performances across the board are grounded, giving weight to material that could easily become too campy or chaotic.
Visually, Five Nights at Freddy’s 2 is a leap forward. Tammi and cinematographer Lyn Moncrief bring a sharper, moodier look to this sequel, with lighting and color choices that enhance both tension and nostalgia. The film frequently indulges in dreamlike stylization: flickering hallways, backlit silhouettes of animatronics, and eerie, music-box-infused sequences that evoke the feel of the games.
The animatronics, once again crafted by the Jim Henson Creature Shop, come alive with an impressive balance of tangibility and menace. Their movements remain slightly uncanny—controlled, slow, and unpredictable—which contributes heavily to the film’s suspense. Even when the film isn’t delivering full-on scares, its atmosphere remains immersive.
The sound design, too, is richly layered. Mechanical whirrs, faint giggles, sudden gear shifts, and music-box cues enhance the unnerving environment without resorting to cheap jumps. This technical proficiency helps elevate scenes that could otherwise feel familiar or predictable.
For fans invested in the game series, Five Nights at Freddy’s 2 will feel like a treasure trove. The film introduces new animatronics, expands on the mythology of the Marionette, incorporates the “Toy” line of characters, and delves into the origins of Freddy Fazbear’s Pizza. These additions feel authentic rather than forced, reflecting Cawthon’s involvement in the screenplay.
The narrative broadens the scope of the franchise by branching beyond one location and integrating new threats, mysteries, and revelations. Despite juggling a larger mythos, the film maintains clarity, giving viewers enough information to follow the increasingly complex supernatural machinery at play. It’s the rare game adaptation that respects its source material not just through references but through tone, character, and world-building.
However, Five Nights at Freddy’s 2 doesn’t fully avoid the issues that held back the first installment. The first act takes its time—sometimes too much time—establishing new characters, teasing lore, and setting up the supernatural mechanics. While this buildup pays off later, viewers may feel impatience early on, especially during dialogue-heavy scenes that sometimes feel stilted or overly expository.
Another drawback is its restraint with on-screen violence. Though the film implies grisly outcomes and maintains a sinister tone, many kills happen off-screen. While this may appeal to a broader audience, it limits the horror’s impact and reduces some sequences to tension without true payoff. Fans seeking a darker, more visceral sequel may find themselves wishing the film took bigger risks.
The scares themselves, though occasionally effective, never quite reach the intensity of the game series or rival genre contemporaries. Suspenseful moments exist—especially those involving dim lighting, toy animatronics, or slow-burn set pieces—but the film often prioritizes mystery and mythology over pure terror. For a franchise built on high-stress survival-horror experiences, that might leave some viewers wanting more.
Despite these issues, Five Nights at Freddy’s 2 succeeds as a continuation of the first film and a bridge toward bigger things. Its commitment to expanding character relationships, fleshing out lore, and conjuring a moody, dreamlike atmosphere gives it a personality distinct from other horror sequels. Tammi directs with confidence and clear affection for the material, and the script—though occasionally clunky—builds a compelling narrative that avoids repeating the first film beat-for-beat.
What emerges is a film that’s more ambitious, more complex, and more emotionally resonant than expected. Even with its milder scares and occasionally slow pacing, it remains engaging thanks to its strong performances, its commitment to world-building, and its reverence for the games’ aesthetics and mythology.
Five Nights at Freddy’s 2 may not be the scariest horror sequel of the year, but it stands as a thoughtful, stylish, and lore-rich addition to the franchise. With standout performances—especially from Hutcherson, Lail, and Rubio—gorgeous cinematography, and a dedication to expanding the mythology in meaningful ways, it offers fans plenty to enjoy. While the slow opening, some clunky dialogue, off-screen kills, and its somewhat muted scare factor prevent it from reaching its full potential, the film remains a satisfying and atmospheric journey deeper into the unsettling world of Freddy Fazbear’s Pizza.
For those invested in the story and the game universe, this sequel is a rewarding and eerie continuation—one that hints at an even darker, more ambitious chapter still to come.
We hope you're enjoying BRWC. You should check us out on our social channels, subscribe to our newsletter, and tell your friends. BRWC is short for battleroyalewithcheese.