Review: Punchline

Review: Punchline

Sexist, backhanded compliments are a sure-fire way to impress a woman in 2018; a sentiment that Punchline relishes in tearing apart. A woman’s basketball practice is interrupted by a man who tells her that she plays as well as a man. For the following few minutes, Punchline focuses on the appropriate reaction to such a comment. It is a premise that works perfectly for a short format, but not one that particularly holds room for development into a longer piece. To serve the agenda, the characters do not succeed a single dimension, though are played wisely by actors Molly McNerney and Bill Evans.


Despite it’s brief running time, Punchline succeeds in entertaining, carefully sidestepping the trap of the “bait and switch” structure most short films favour. The plot relies on an inherently cinematic trope – a protagonist imagines what they wish they could say or do, before it is revealed what actually happened. A technique used particularly strongly in films like Ben Stiller’s The Secret Life of Walter Mitty, writer/director Zen Kiddo takes things a step further. Defining the polish term “Jouska” at the beginning of the film, Kiddo is able to repeat the inciting event not just once but multiple times, allowing the protagonist to determine which of her many options was the correct response to have.

Unapologetic and more than a little relevant, Kiddo’s film is a testament to a rightfully prevailing attitude in cinema, and the western world in general. Female characters who aren’t defined by their male screen partners are a scarcity in film, but film’s like this are a step in the right direction. Perhaps one day a woman will be able to play basketball without the insufferable comments of a man, but until then we’re happy to see said woman fighting back. Indicating Kiddo’s knowledge and ability, Punchline wears it’s influences proudly on it’s sleeve, or printed on it’s basketball in this case. As short films go, this one is very much worth the few minutes of play time, even if you can guess the ending by reading the title.

We hope you're enjoying BRWC. You should check us out on our socal channels, subscribe to our newsletter, and tell your friends. BRWC is short for battleroyalewithcheese.

Trending on BRWC:


The BRWC Xmas 2018 Gift Guide!

By Alton Williams / 30th November 2018

ENDED: Win #EmilyAtack’s Latest Movie, Lies We Tell!

By Alton Williams / 26th November 2018
All The Devil's Men

ENDED – All The Devil’s Men: T-Shirt Comp!

By Alton Williams / 22nd November 2018

BRWC EXCLUSIVE INTERVIEW: James Dylan, Cargo Director

By Alton Williams / 29th November 2018

Aquaman: World Premiere Live Stream

By Alton Williams / 26th November 2018

Dan will watch just about any film he can get his hands on. His ultimate goal is to see all of the films, but for now he's happy obsessing over anything with a brilliant script and/or well executed violence. Some of his favourite directors include Quentin Tarantino, Michael Haneke, Stanley Kubrick, Chan-wook Park, Christopher Nolan and Martin Scorsese.


Sorry, the comment form is closed at this time.